top of page
Writer's pictureJim McCullough

Veteran Asserts First Amendment Right by Yelling 'There is no fire' in Crowded Theater

Updated: Mar 9, 2024

In an unprecedented display of constitutional freedom, a local senior citizen, Herbert Clingstone, took it upon himself to exercise his First Amendment right in the most unexpected manner. In the middle of a packed premiere at the historic Grandiose Theater, Herbert stood up, cleared his throat, and with the conviction of a man who has seen it all, bellowed, "There is no fire!" into the bewildered crowd.

Herbert with George Washington and Patton the Parrot.

A Bold Statement on Freedom of Speech


The incident, which took place last Saturday night, has since sparked a nationwide debate on the boundaries of free speech and the responsibilities that come with it. Witnesses report a mix of confusion, panic, and an awkward silence that followed Herbert's proclamation. 


"It was like he was trying to reassure us, but nobody was worried in the first place," said one theatergoer, who preferred to remain anonymous. "I dropped my popcorn. That's a whole eight bucks gone, just like that."


Herbert, a retired postal worker and self-proclaimed constitutional enthusiast, defended his actions by citing his unwavering belief in the First Amendment. "Everyone's always talking about shouting 'fire' in a crowded theater. Well, I figured it was high time someone tested the waters in the opposite direction," he explained from his recliner, surrounded by stacks of constitutional law books and a pet parrot that has learned to squawk "free speech!"


The Legal and Social Quagmire


Legal experts are divided on the issue, with some arguing that Herbert's actions, though bizarre, don't violate any laws. Others, however, suggest that causing any public disturbance, even with the best intentions, could tread a fine line.


"In a world where misinformation spreads like wildfire, yelling about non-existent fires, or the lack thereof, might just be the next frontier in free speech debates," commented Professor Lila Moore, a leading constitutional law expert at an unnamed but very prestigious university.


Public Reaction: From Outrage to Meme


Public reaction has been varied, ranging from outrage and calls for Herbert to be banned from all public events to a more humorous take on social media, where memes of Herbert's declaration have gone viral. One popular meme features Herbert's bewildered face with the caption, "When you're so woke, you extinguish fires that aren't even there."


In response to the incident, the Grandiose Theater has announced plans to implement "Herbert Drills," where staff and patrons will practice the appropriate response to false alarms of any kind. "It's all about preparedness," said the theater manager, trying to find the silver lining in an otherwise perplexing situation.


Conclusion: A Nation Ponders


As the dust settles and the memes proliferate, the nation is left to ponder the true meaning of free speech and its implications in modern society. Herbert Clingstone, meanwhile, remains unrepentant, viewing himself as a pioneer on the frontier of constitutional rights.


"I've got more statements to make," Herbert declared, a twinkle in his eye. "Next week, I'm thinking of going to the library to whisper 'There's no silence' in the quiet section. It's all about balance, you see."


In a world increasingly divided on issues of freedom and responsibility, perhaps it's the Herberts of the world who remind us of the fine line between liberty and lunacy.


(c) Copyright Jim McCullough 2024


47 views

Recent Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page